Read also Article reserved for our subscribers Competition and antitrust: what are Facebook, Google, Amazon and Apple accused of?
Despite this preamble, the parliamentary hearing was a bit disappointing: some questions showed a lack of knowledge on the part of the elected representatives – “Why would a 9-year-old child prefer to watch a video of someone playing Fortnite rather than playing himself?” asked one of them. Few new elements emerged, nor concrete legislative solutions. But the nearly two-hour session allowed to measure the degree of hostility – bipartisan, but a little higher among Democrats – of the representatives and their points of concern. Moreover, this hearing is only the beginning of the subcommittee’s investigation. Above all, it is accompanied by other investigations and reflections on competition law applied to digital.
The World
Special offer for students and teachers
Access all our content unlimited from €6.99/month instead of €12.99.

Subscribe
To the point where Brian Acton, one of the creators of WhatsApp, left Facebook in 2017 and then explained that the logic linked to the deployment of advertising in its application went against its principles. To ensure funding without advertising, WhatsApp had for a time set up a very modest annual subscription system (one dollar per year). The acquisition by Facebook in 2014, for the astronomical sum of 19 billion euros , then led to the application becoming entirely free, on the model of all social networks provided by Facebook – whose free nature is normally financed by advertising.
But WhatsApp's message encryption, a core principle that Mark Zuckerberg reaffirmed in 2019 , is a thorn in Facebook's side in allowing the collection of users' personal data, on which these ads rely.